`Harry potter and the order of the pheonix…critique
February 11, 2008`Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix is a great book written by J.K Rowling but as far as a I see it, it’s not perfect. Yes the book had many “suspenseful”, amazing, life changing events, but yet most if the event endings are given in the “suspense” that the author is trying to create for the reader. A quick example, when Harry is taken to Dumbledore to tell him about his dream, Dumbledore doesn’t pay attention to Harry and makes him impatient, as the author was trying to create suspense about what Harry was going to do she basically made it easier for me to know that Voldemort is going to do something to him. Now I’m not saying that the whole book was like that, I’m just saying that yes the book was great but very few but major ad ends. As many people would rate it a 4+ I am rating it a 3.5 out of 5, the book is good but not as good as what expected from this author. This author has written great books but I wouldn’t classify this when as one of them.
Hey Ehsan,
Nice review. I think you did a well job eplaining it. There is no summary. And what is Ad. Thanks!
Hey Ehsan!
Nice entry but I don’t necceraliy agree with you. This book is basically a fantasy and if you don’t like reading these type of books don’t pick them, this was a good book, seriously. Anywayz u have ur on ideas
Nice work!
Abdullah
Hey worm,
This is a gr8 post. It described the bokk very good. Although ur point of view about Harry is diffrent than mine, I can understsand what the heck the book is talkin about
Gr8 job nooblet
Comment on me!!!! (Cland wars this thursday?)
Srry clan wars
Oh ya, 3rd comment.
Ur right this book wasn’t on of my favorite from the series. Couldnt u comment on the 4th, it was the third best in my point of view.
7th is best, 6th is second best
Though Harry Potter is my favorite book in all times, I do have to disagree with you. Maybe I’m wrong but you shouldn’t really look at all the bad points of a book but the good points, your critique is interesting because you talk about GOOD and BAD points but for me it’s either I’m please with a book or I’m not! Good luck with the rest of the series!
Nayef
I agree with you, Ehsan. The Order of the Phoenix is an interesting book but in a way, it is not actually the best among all of J.K Rowling’s books. To me, it is a bit cramped.
But she did a great job, writing the best series of all times.
Try the last installment, the Deathly Hallows. It may interest you.
hey….nic post ehsan…..hop u ENJOYD the book….hav fun!!